Yours and Mine Cake Design
Imaginations Made Edible

Our Current Menu with Price List

If you do not see something that would tickle your taste buds, let us know we would be happy to customize a cake just for you and your special occasion. We do ask for at least two weeks notice in order for us to collaborate with you and design your perfect cake.

Our Menu

Cake Shots and Our CUPCAKES
SMASH and Anniversary Cakes
Tiered Cakes
Cake Flavors
Filling Flavors
Frosting Flavors
Special Combinations
Cake Shots and Our CUPCAKES

This is the same great cake that you expect and deserve, just cut into pieces to fit into the cup or shot size of your choice. Brides are saying it is the hottest thing right now. Your guest are not obligated to eat cake right away. Their cake is packaged so they can take it home if they like. Little to no mess, so that means easy clean up. No extra cost for cutting and platting cake. Your wedding colors or coordinating colors can be incorporated with out hassle. Create beautiful displays with lights and other embellishments to coordinate with your wedding theme. They can be decorated as you choose. We can organized them as a center piece for the tables. Endless colors, flavors, fillings and styles. Pick your own size and style of cups/shots and let your imagination run wild. If you have any questions about our new Cupcake or Cake shots please contact us.

Pricing based on cup/shot size. Special pricing for large orders.

CUPCAKE Lids and cake shots are only available in limited sizes. Please contact us with the size you desire so we can confirm lids are available.


Available with: drizzle, fruit, peanut butter, chocolate chip and Oreo.

Crusts: Graham cracker, Oreo and Nilla wafer.

Available in mini (1 to 2 bites) and single serving (3 to 4 bites) Special pricing available for large orders.

Caramel Crunch: Starting with a graham cracker crust then we add a fluffy cheesecake with Twix mixed in and we top it off with more Twix, chocolate and caramel drizzle.

Chocolate Chip: Starting off with your favorite crust and we add mini chocolate chips to our cheesecake, then top it off with chocolate drizzle and more mini chocolate chips.

Chocolate Dream: Oreo crust, dreamy chocolate cheesecake topped with a wonderful chocolate sauce and crushed Oreo's.

Crisp Caramel Apple: Starting off with a graham/oats crust and then we add a creamy cheesecake, topping it off with fresh apply slices and caramel.

Double Cookie: Start off with chocolate chip cookie then a Oreo cookie layer, now add the smooth cheesecake and top it with more Oreo crushed cookies. Mmmm cookies.

Jealous Girl Scout: You don't have to wait till cookie time for this one! A graham cracker crust with a yummy cheesecake center topped with caramel coconut and a chocolate drizzle.

Jubilee Cherries: Starting with a cherry chip base and a creamy cheesecake center and finish it off with a dollop of whipped cream.

Oreo: Starting off with an Oreo crust then we add crushed Oreo's to our cheesecake and top it off with mini Oreo. You can also request your favorite Oreo flavor.

Peanut Butterfinger: Start off with and Oreo crust then we will add a peanut butter cheesecake with butterfinger pieces and we will top it off with crushed butterfingers.

Peanut Butter Heaven: Starting with yummy nutter butter's and Reese's, continue with the peanut butter cheesecake now adding another layer of nutter butters and Reese's, ooh heaven.

Pumpkin: Graham cracker crust with a wonderful pumpkin cheesecake topped with cream cheese and a caramel drizzle.

Peppermint: Starting with a mint Oreo crust then adding a peppermint cheesecake and topping it off with a chocolate drizzle.

Offered seasonally with candy canes.

Tiramisu: Starting with a coffee sugar cookie base then add the cheesecake middle don't forget the whipped cream topping.

Best Cheesecake: Starting with your favorite crust add cheesecake and then your favorite topping, choose from many fruit flavors, chocolate, caramel drizzle or let us combine flavors for you. Let your taste buds dance, the options are endless.

Whipped Cream, Cream Cheese, Tart-lets and Cheesecakes are not recommended for outside summer events.


We are offering mini tart-lets (1-2 bites) and regular tart-lets (3-4 bites). Flavors available are strawberry, blueberry, cherry, mixed berry and S'more. Special pricing available for large orders.

SMASH and Anniversary Cakes

Free 4" SMASH cake with purchase of either a 8" or larger birthday cake, or 24 cupcakes.

Free 6' basic 1 year anniversary cake with wedding purchase.

Tiered Cakes

2 tiers or larger. Each tier is an average of 4' tall, tiers may be made taller for a additional charge.

Cake Flavors

French Vanilla




Red Velvet





Peanut Butter

Key Lime

Almond Sour Cream White and Chocolate

Chocolate Chip






Butter Pecan

Have a favorite flavor but don't see it listed? We can customize a flavor just for you.

*Whipped Cream, Cream Cheese, Tart-lets and Cheesecakes are not recommended for outside summer events.

Filling Flavors

Cream Cheese






Cookies & Cream

Peanut Butter


Pudding Fillings available in many flavors

Our frosting flavors can also be used as fillings

Whipped Cream, Cream Cheese, Tart-lets and Cheesecakes are not recommended for outside summer events.

Frosting Flavors

Butter cream




Peanut Butter

*Whipped Cream

*Cream Cheese Mocha

*Irish Cream


Frosting flavors can also be used as fillings

Do not see your favorite flavor? Don't forget we customize.

Add $2.00 charge per dz for premium frosting's. No extra charge for alcoholic cake flavors or frosting if alcohol is provided (remaining will be returned).

Whipped Cream, Cream Cheese, Tart-lets and Cheesecakes are not recommended for outside summer events.

Special Combinations

Almond Joy - White almond cake with almond buttercream, coconut and a chocolate drizzle.

Apple Pie - Spice cake with apple filling, spiced buttercream and crushed graham crackers.

Banana Cream - Banana cake with a vanilla pudding filling, whipped cream and chocolate drizzle to top it off.

Black and White - White Almond Sour Cream cake layered with chocolate butter cream or switch it up with Chocolate Sour Cream cake layered with white butter cream filling.

Bridal Bliss - Our most popular wedding flavor, white almond sour cream cake with raspberry filling and butter cream frosting.

Butter Pecan - Butter cake with glazed pecans baked right in. Choose your favorite frosting and enjoy.

Candy Bar Blast - Choose your favorite candy bar and put it in your favorite batter. Then top it off with your favorite frosting and crushed candy.

Chitty, Chitty, Bang, Bang - Carrot cake with a cheesecake filling with a rumchata buttercream.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough - White cake filled with chocolate chip cookie dough then add your favorite frosting.

Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake - Chocolate cake swirled with cheesecake topped with a smooth buttercream and raspberry sauce.

Cookies and Cream - White or Chocolate cake with Oreo cookies baked right in and your choice of frosting and Oreo's crushed on top. You may pick your favorite Oreo flavor to use. Please keep in mind some Oreo flavors are only offered seasonally.

Dutch Treat - White cake with windmill cookie pieces baked in. Top it with a smooth buttercream and crushed windmill cookie.

Graham crackers in my - Start with frosted graham crackers, now layer with white or chocolate cake, fill it with a cream cheese graham mix, then top it off with a light buttercream and crushed frosted grahams.

Grandma’s carrot cake - Carrot cake with raisins. Like walnuts in your cake? We can add it. Pair with cream cheese frosting, yum.

Lemon Dream - Lemon cake with your choice of frosting. Add a little extra and include a lemon filing.

Mint Chocolate chip - Your choice of white or chocolate cake with a hint of mint and chocolate chips. Add your favorite frosting and a Andes mint on top.

Mimosa* - Start off with white cake, add champagne, orange juice and a few more special ingredients and you have a refreshing cupcake to enjoy.

Mojito* - Add a little rum and a hint if mint in our white cake and you have our version of a Mojito.

Moose Tracks - Chocolate Chip cake with peanut butter filling and chocolate frosting.

Mudslide* - Chocolate cake filled with Kahlua butter cream topped with Irish cream butter cream and chocolate drizzle.

Orange Dreamsicle - Orange cake with cream cheese filling and frosting.

Oreo mud pie - Chocolate cake with a chocolate pudding center, cookies and cream frosting with Oreo crumbled on top with a gummy worm.

Peanut Butter Cup - Chocolate cake with peanut butter filling and frosting. Or make it a PB bliss with PB cake, filling and frosting.

Pumpkin Yum - Pumpkin spice cake infused with caramel, cream cheese filling and frosting.

Red Velvet - Red velvet cake with cream cheese.

Root Beer Float - Root beer flavored cake with root beer frosting and a edible straw.

S'more Please - Chocolate cake with a marshmallow center and a graham cracker crumble on buttercream.

Strawberry Cheesecake - Strawberry cake with a cheesecake center, a smooth cream cheese frosting and graham cracker crumble.

Strawberry Lemonade - Lemon cake with a strawberry filling and a light and fluffy frosting. Or

strawberry cake with lemon filling.

Summer Time - White cake with a fudge center, buttercream with a caramel drizzle and waffle cone pieces.

Tropical Paradise - Key lime cake with key lime frosting.

Add $2.00 charge per dz for premium frosting's. No extra charge for alcoholic cake flavors or frosting if alcohol is provided (remaining will be returned).

Our Current Prices

Please Note...

Serving sizes are approximate and based on wedding servings size

Fresh flower decoration to be provided by customer

Extra charge may apply for detailed decorations

Ribbon or embellishments to be provided by customer

Allergen & Alcohol Notice

Our products may contain egg, wheat, milk, nuts, gluten, alcohol, and soy. Our products are made on equipment that also processes products containing peanuts.

Please beware when ordering alcohol containing baked goods that not all the alcohol is baked out. Must be 21 years of age to purchase alcohol containing products. We will confirm ID on delivery/pick up. We are not responsible nor liable for any misjudgment, decision making, vehicle violations and or injuries that may occur during or after consumption of our products that contain alcohol. PURCHASER OF ALCOHOL CONTAINING PRODUCTS TAKE FULL RESPONSIBILITY AND LIABILITY FOR PERSONAL AND OR PRIVATE ACTIONS AND PROPERTY. 

Cancellation Policies

Wedding Cancellations: Please contact us two weeks prior to your wedding date if cancellation is needed. Deposits made are non refundable without two week notice.

Other Desserts: A 72 hour notice is requested if you are unable to keep your dessert order. Deposits not refundable with out a 72 hour cancellation.

Prices, sizes, shapes, fillings, flavors and combinations are subject to change without notice.

Event Venues

Yours and Mine Cake Design works with each of these venues to help you plan the perfect event.

Don't see your venue, no worries. We work with many local and outer area venues. Let us do the work, we would be happy to contact your venue and make all necessary arrangements.

Bay Pointe Inn (Shelbyville)​

Scheltema Barn (Caledonia)

Centennial Barn (Wayland)

Historic Bowens Mills (Middleville)

Vann's Valley (Shelbyville)

Ever After (Hastings)

The Silo (Allegan)​

The Barn at Monterey Valley (Allegan)

The Goie Center (Grand Rapids)

The Grand Rapids Public Museum (Grand Rapids)

The Gathering (Allegan)

City Flats (Grand Rapids/Holland)

Walldorff Ballroom (Hastings)

Brides on a Budget (Caledonia)

Comfort Inn (Plainwell)​

Orchard Hills Golf Course (Shelbyville)

The Lynx Events (Otsego)